South African scientists have joined malaria experts from around the world to lobby against the European Unions (EUs) plans to introduce stringent new pesticide rules, which they say will hamper Africas fight against malaria.
The European Parliament is expected to vote today on new pesticide regulations that will restrict their use in the EU. Although pesticides are primarily used for protecting crops, many are also used in small quantities to kill insects that spread diseases. For example, malaria-carrying mosquitoes are controlled using insecticide-treated bed nets and by spraying small amounts of insecticide inside houses.
The scientists fear that if pesticide manufacturers lose their agricultural markets in Europe, they will go out of business and leave other countries hard-hit by insect-borne diseases such as malaria and dengue without supplies.
About 40% of the worlds population is at risk of malaria, according to the World Health Organisation (WHO). More than half a million people fall severely ill with the disease each year, most of them in sub-Saharan Africa.
Production for public health is usually a discretionary, mostly philanthropic, extra. A review of public health pesticide products by the Boston Consulting Group for the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation estimated the total public health market was worth only $750m in 2006, or 1,3% of the total pesticide market, the UK-based Campaign for Fighting Diseases (CFD) lobby group said in a report last week.
Even if chemical production does not cease entirely, supply and competition would certainly decline, resulting in higher prices and lower quality. What happens within the EU pesticides market has a large global influence, as Europe produces a quarter of all the worlds pesticides, the report said.
The regulations would also reduce incentives to invest in research for new insecticides, which were desperately needed as there was growing resistance to the handful available for combating disease-carrying bugs, CFD spokeswoman Caroline Boin said.
A total of 160 scientists and malaria experts from around the world signed a petition last year urging the EU to reconsider the legislation. Signatories included Richard Feachem, former head of the Global Fund for AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria; David King, former chief scientist to the UK government; Prof Maureen Coetzee, chair of medical entomology at the University of the Witwatersrand; Anglo Americans Brian Brink; and scientists from the Medical Research Council.
I dont think the people in the EU that proposed these regulations thought them through, Coetzee said.
The scientists said the proposed regulations would also harm Africas agricultural trade, as the EU would not tolerate residues of deregistered pesticides on imports.
Source:Tamar Kahn,
SA scientists oppose EU pesticide rules Business Day, January 13, 2008
For text:
http://www.businessday.co.za/articles/topstories.aspx?ID=BD4A917238
FMF Policy Bulletin/ 13 January 2009